Back to Blog
team systems
29 January 20246 min read

Why Your New Hire Onboarding Is Probably Broken (And How to Fix It)

Most businesses massively underinvest in onboarding. Here's what great onboarding actually looks like and how to build it.

JP

Jordan Patel

Systemantic

Why Your New Hire Onboarding Is Probably Broken (And How to Fix It)

Here's a number that should concern you: at most growing businesses, it takes new hires 3-6 months to become fully productive.

Six months. Half a year of salary before someone is contributing at their potential. Multiply that by every hire you make, and you're looking at a massive hidden cost.

Now, some ramp-up time is inevitable. Complex roles require learning. But most of that 3-6 months isn't learning the actual job-it's figuring out how things work. Where information lives. Who to ask. How decisions get made. The unwritten rules nobody told them.

That's not a learning problem. That's an onboarding problem.

The Typical Onboarding Experience

Let me describe what onboarding looks like at most growing businesses:

Day 1: Laptop setup takes half the morning. HR paperwork. A brief intro meeting with the manager. Maybe a quick tour (virtual or physical). Access to Slack, where 47 channels await with no context about which matter.

Week 1: A scattering of intro meetings, depending on who remembered to schedule them. Some documentation that may or may not be current. A lot of figuring things out through Slack archaeology. The phrase 'just ask if you need anything' repeated many times.

Month 1: Gradually piecing together how things actually work through observation and asking colleagues who are too busy to explain things properly. Making mistakes due to missing context. Feeling like a burden.

Months 2-6: Slowly accumulating the knowledge that should have been transferred in week one. Finally becoming useful, right around the time you've forgotten how painful the ramp-up was.

Sound familiar?

Why Onboarding Breaks

Onboarding fails for predictable reasons:

1. It's nobody's job

Everyone assumes someone else is handling it. The manager thinks HR is owning it. HR thinks the manager is. The result is gaps everywhere.

2. Knowledge lives in heads

The information new hires need exists-but it's scattered across Slack history, outdated wiki pages, and the memories of people too busy to download it all.

3. There's no structure

Without a clear path, new hires wander. They don't know what they don't know. They're afraid to ask basic questions. They waste time on things that don't matter.

4. Existing employees are drowning

The people who should be onboarding new hires are the same people overwhelmed with their actual jobs. Training falls to the bottom of the priority list.

5. Nobody measures it

What gets measured gets managed. Most businesses don't track onboarding effectiveness, so they don't know it's broken until new hire turnover spikes or productivity disappoints.

What Great Onboarding Looks Like

Effective onboarding has three characteristics:

It's structured. There's a clear path from Day 1 to full productivity, with milestones and checkpoints along the way.

It's self-serve (mostly). New hires can learn the basics without monopolising colleagues' time. They know where to find information and can progress independently through foundational material.

It's consistent. Every new hire gets the same high-quality experience, regardless of who their manager is or how busy the team is when they join.

Building Better Onboarding: A Practical Framework

1. Define What 'Productive' Means

Before you can accelerate the path to productivity, you need to define the destination. For each role:

  • What does 'fully productive' look like?
  • What should someone be able to do independently after Week 1? Month 1? Month 3?
  • What knowledge and skills are required?
  • What relationships need to be established?

Be specific. 'Understands our processes' is too vague. 'Can process a customer order end-to-end without assistance' is measurable.

2. Create an Onboarding Hub

New hires need a single place that contains everything they need to know. Not scattered across ten tools-one central hub.

This hub should include:

  • **Company context:** History, mission, values, culture, organisational structure
  • **Role-specific information:** Expectations, responsibilities, success metrics
  • **How we work:** Key processes, tools, communication norms, decision-making
  • **Key resources:** Documentation, templates, guides, FAQs
  • **Who's who:** Team introductions, org chart, key contacts

Notion, Confluence, or a simple internal wiki can work. What matters is that it's maintained and that new hires know to start there.

3. Design the First Week

The first week sets the tone. Design it intentionally:

Before Day 1:

  • Equipment shipped and ready
  • Accounts and access provisioned
  • Welcome email with what to expect
  • Calendar pre-populated with key meetings

Day 1:

  • Morning: Setup and orientation to the onboarding hub
  • Midday: Lunch with manager or buddy
  • Afternoon: Begin structured learning path

Days 2-5:

  • Self-paced learning through onboarding hub
  • Scheduled intro meetings with key colleagues
  • First small tasks to apply learning
  • Daily check-in with manager or buddy

4. Build Learning Paths

Not everything can be learned from documentation. Design a structured path that combines:

  • **Self-serve content:** Reading, videos, walkthroughs
  • **Hands-on exercises:** Real tasks with training wheels
  • **Shadowing:** Observing experienced colleagues
  • **Coaching:** 1:1 time with knowledgeable team members

Sequence matters. Start with foundational knowledge, then build to role-specific skills. Include checkpoints to confirm understanding before moving on.

5. Assign Onboarding Buddies

Every new hire should have a buddy-someone who's not their manager but is responsible for helping them navigate.

The buddy's job:

  • Answer 'stupid questions' without judgment
  • Provide cultural context ('here's how things really work')
  • Make introductions and inclusion happen
  • Check in regularly during the first month

Choose buddies carefully. They should be knowledgeable, approachable, and not so overwhelmed they can't give time to the role.

6. Set Expectations and Milestones

New hires shouldn't wonder if they're on track. Build in clear milestones:

Week 1 milestone: Completed onboarding hub orientation, met key team members, understands role expectations.

Month 1 milestone: Can perform core job functions with some support, understands key processes, is integrated into team routines.

Month 3 milestone: Fully productive, operating independently, contributing at expected level.

Schedule checkpoint conversations at each milestone. Make expectations explicit so there's no anxiety about unspoken standards.

7. Iterate Based on Feedback

Onboarding should improve with each new hire. Build in feedback loops:

  • Week 1 survey: How's the experience so far? What's missing?
  • Month 1 conversation: What was helpful? What was confusing?
  • Month 3 retrospective: What would you change about onboarding?

Act on the feedback. Update documentation, adjust the schedule, fill gaps. The best onboarding programmes are constantly evolving.

The ROI of Better Onboarding

Investing in onboarding pays off in multiple ways:

  • **Faster productivity:** Reduce ramp time from months to weeks
  • **Better retention:** New hires who feel supported are more likely to stay
  • **Reduced burden:** Self-serve onboarding frees up existing team members
  • **Improved consistency:** Every hire gets the same great start
  • **Preserved knowledge:** Documentation benefits everyone, not just new hires

The time you spend building proper onboarding is an investment that compounds with every hire you make.

Getting Started

You don't need to build the perfect onboarding programme overnight. Start with:

1. Create an onboarding hub with the basics

2. Design a structured first week

3. Assign buddies

4. Set clear milestones

5. Gather feedback and iterate

Every improvement makes the next hire's experience better-and makes your team more effective at integrating new members.

Tags:
onboarding
hiring
team
processes
JP

Jordan Patel

Operations consultant at Systemantic, helping growing businesses build systems that scale.

Need help implementing these ideas?

We help growing businesses build systems that actually work. Let's talk about your operational challenges.